Characteristics and risk factors associated with missed diagnosis in patients with smear-negative pulmonary tuberculosis
Article information
Abstract
Background/Aims
Delayed diagnosis and treatment of smear-negative pulmonary tuberculosis (TB) are major concerns for TB control. We evaluated characteristics of patients with smear-negative pulmonary TB who received a delayed diagnosis and identified risk factors that may have contributed to this delay.
Methods
We reviewed medical records of patients with smear-negative culture-positive pulmonary TB treated at a tertiary care hospital in South Korea between January 2017 and December 2018. Patients who initiated anti-TB treatment after positive cultures were included in the missed TB group, and those who initiated empirical treatment before positive cultures were included in the control group.
Results
Of 220 patients included, 117 (53.2%) and 103 (46.8%) were in the missed TB and control groups, respectively. Patients in the missed TB group were older (p = 0.001) and had a higher mean body mass index (BMI) (p = 0.019). Comorbidities (66.9% vs. 46.6%, p = 0.003) and immunocompromised patients (33.1% vs. 20.4%, p = 0.035) were more common in the missed TB group than in the control group. Old age (odds ratio [OR], 1.030; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.012 to 1.048; p = 0.001), high BMI (OR, 1.114; 95% CI, 1.004 to 1.237; p = 0.042), and negative polymerase chain reaction (PCR) results (OR, 9.551; 95% CI, 4.925 to 18.521; p < 0.001) were associated with delayed diagnosis.
Conclusions
In more than half of patients with smear-negative pulmonary TB, the diagnosis was delayed. Patients with delayed TB diagnosis were older, had higher BMI, and negative PCR results.
INTRODUCTION
Tuberculosis (TB) is the leading cause of death from a single epidemic disease worldwide [1], and it remains a global health problem despite advances in its diagnosis and treatment. The global incidence of TB is currently declining 1.5% per year [1], and to achieve the World Health Organization (WHO) End TB Strategy targets, this reduction rate needs to be increased by 4% to 5% per year by 2020 [2].
To reach the goals of the WHO End TB Strategy, early diagnosis to prevent TB spread is one of the most important factors for reducing the incidence of TB [3]. To enable early detection and diagnosis, the sensitivity and specificity of TB diagnostic tools must be improved. Sputum smear microscopy has been used as a primary method for diagnosing TB [4]; however, the sensitivity of this method is reportedly only 50% to 60% [5].
Because it may take a long time before TB culture test results are confirmed, not initiating TB treatment until a positive culture report is received may result in delayed diagnosis. This, in turn, may delay optimal treatment, lead to poor treatment outcomes, and increase the risk of transmission in the hospital and community. For the rapid diagnosis of smear-negative pulmonary TB, TB polymerase chain reaction (PCR), which includes the Xpert MTB/RIF assay (Xpert, Cepheid, Sunnyvale, CA, USA), is performed; however, this assay is not sufficiently sensitive and not fully implemented in real-world settings. Therefore, delayed diagnosis and treatment of smear-negative pulmonary TB are major concerns for TB control in low- and intermediate-burden areas.
We, therefore, aimed to evaluate the clinical characteristics and radiologic findings of patients with smear-negative pulmonary TB whose diagnosis and treatment were delayed and to identify risk factors that may have contributed to the delayed diagnosis.
METHODS
Study population and design
We conducted this single-center retrospective study at a tertiary care hospital in South Korea between January 2017 and December 2018. Patients with smear-negative and culture-positive pulmonary TB were retrospectively identified. The Institutional Review Board at Severance Hospital approved this retrospective study and waived the need for informed consent for access to electric medical records (IRB No. 2019-2828-001).
Patients and data collection
Medical records of 307 adult patients (aged ≥ 18 years) with smear-negative and culture-positive pulmonary TB were evaluated. Smears were considered positive if acid-fast bacteria (on auramine-rhodamine staining) were observed in the smears of any of the respiratory specimens [6]. We included only patients diagnosed with pulmonary TB according to the WHO [7] and Korean TB guidelines [8], i.e., a diagnosis that was based on a positive culture from a spontaneous sputum sample, an induced sputum sample, or bronchoalveolar lavage. From this patient group, we excluded patients with extra-pulmonary TB, those who had already initiated treatment at another hospital, those who were not prescribed medication at our hospital, and those who were currently under treatment.
The following data were collected from each patient’s medical record: demographic data (sex, age, body mass index [BMI]), presence of comorbidities (immunocompromised condition, hypertension, diabetes mellitus, chronic kidney disease, and respiratory disease), smoking status, and prior history of TB treatment. Immunocompromised patients were defined as (1) hematopoietic cell transplant recipients; (2) other solid organ transplant recipients; (3) patients with malignancies who were receiving chemotherapy; and (4) patients who received any immunosuppressive treatments (e.g., biologic agents targeting inflammatory mediators, or corticosteroid therapy). Patients who smoked at least once in their lifetime were classified as smokers. Furthermore, we reviewed other medical records, including clinical TB forms, reports of symptoms at diagnosis, radiographic findings, and diagnostic methods.
Classification of the study population
The study population was divided into two groups based on whether anti-TB treatment was initiated before or after receiving positive culture results. Patients who initiated anti-TB treatment after the confirmation of positive culture results were included in the missed TB group, and those who initiated empirical treatment before obtaining the final culture results were included in the control group.
Treatment outcomes
Treatment outcomes were defined according to the WHO [9] and Korean TB guidelines [8]. A favorable outcome was defined as a cure and/or treatment completion without relapse, and an unfavorable outcome was defined as treatment failure, death during treatment, or relapse after completing the initial treatment.
Statistical analysis
Data are presented as the number of cases and the median (interquartile range [IQR]). Categorical comparisons were performed using the chi-square test, and continuous variables were compared using the Mann–Whitney test or t test. Multivariate logistic regression analysis was performed to evaluate factors potentially associated with a delayed diagnosis of TB. The odds ratios (ORs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were also calculated. A p value < 0.05 was considered significant for all analyses. Data analysis was performed using SPSS version 25 (Released 2017, IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA).
RESULTS
Study population
From January 2017 to December 2018, 307 patients with smear-negative and culture-positive TB were enrolled in this study. Of the 307 patients, 87 were excluded, and 220 patients met the inclusion criteria. Of these 220 patients, 117 (53.2%) were included in the missed TB group and 103 (46.8%) were included in the control group (Fig. 1).
Flow chart of the study population. TB, tuberculosis.
Baseline characteristics
Baseline characteristics of the study population are summarized in Table 1. The study population had a median age of 58.0 years (IQR, 39.3 to 71.0). Compared with patients in the control group, those in the missed TB group were older (median age, 49.0 years [IQR, 33.0 to 69.0] vs. 63.0 years [IQR, 48.5 to 72.5]; p = 0.001) and had significantly higher BMI (21.6 kg/m2 [IQR, 19.5 to 23.4] vs. 22.4 kg/m2 [IQR, 20.0 to 24.7], p = 0.019). The presence of any comorbidities (79 [66.9%] vs. 48 [46.6%], p = 0.003) and immunocompromised conditions (39 [33.1%] vs. 21 [20.4%], p = 0.035) were more common in the missed TB group than in the control group. There were no significant differences in sex, smoking status, or prior history of TB treatment between the two groups.
Baseline characteristics
The most common symptoms experienced by patients before being diagnosed with TB were cough and sputum production (64 [29.1%] and 43 [19.5%], respectively). There were no significant differences between the two groups regarding whether symptoms developed before TB was diagnosed (52 [50.5%] vs. 64 [54.7%], p = 0.589). In total, 216 (98.2%) patients underwent chest computed tomography (CT), and four (1.8%) underwent only chest X-ray. Fewer patients in the missed TB group than in the control group presented with a cavitating lesion on chest X-ray or chest CT (24 [23.3%] vs. 12 [10.3%], p = 0.011). In addition to the smear/culture examination, patients underwent other diagnostic tests, including PCR and interferon-gamma release assay (IGRA). In total, 30.9% of patients underwent IGRA, of whom 95.6% showed positive results. There were no significant differences between the two groups in terms of the proportion of patients with positive IGRA results (37 [97.4%] vs. 28 [93.3%], p = 0.056). Furthermore, 92.3% of patients underwent PCR, including Xpert MTB/RIF assay, and 47.8% of patients with positive cultures also had positive PCR results. The proportion of positive PCR results was lower in the missed TB group than in the control group (26 [25.5%] vs. 71 [70.3%], p < 0.001) (Table 1 and Fig. 2).
Proportion of positive polymerase chain reaction (PCR), including Xpert MTB/RIF assay (Xpert, Cepheid, Sunnyvale, CA, USA) and results.
Table 2 shows working diagnoses for patients in the missed TB group before pulmonary TB was confirmed and the reasons for initiating anti-TB treatment before obtaining culture results for patients in the control group. Clinicians considered the possibility of TB at the first visit in 71 (60.7%) patients. Of these 71 patients, 27 (38.0%) were treated with antibiotics before the diagnosis of TB to rule out pulmonary TB. Differential diagnoses considered by clinicians for patients in the missed TB group included pneumonia (n = 24, 20.5%) and lung cancer (n = 8, 6.8%). Patients who initiated anti-TB treatment before obtaining culture results were treated based on positive PCR results (n = 48, 46.6%), radiographic findings (n = 27, 26.2%), radiographic findings and PCR (n = 20, 19.4%), pathology results (n = 4, 3.9%), pathology and PCR (n = 3, 2.9%), or clinical symptoms (n = 1, 1.0%).
Working diagnoses in the missed TB group and the reasons for starting anti-TB treatment before obtaining the culture results in the control group
Clinical treatment outcomes
Clinical treatment outcomes are shown in Table 3. The median duration from the date of culture testing to the start of treatment was 3.0 days (IQR, 0.0 to 7.0) in the control group and 25.0 days (IQR, 21.0 to 29.0) in the missed TB group (p < 0.001), indicating that anti-TB treatment was initiated significantly later in the missed TB group than in the control group (Table 3 and Fig. 3). During the median follow-up of 559.0 days (IQR, 311.0 to 767.0), 190 (86.4%) patients were treated successfully with favorable outcomes, including cure and treatment completion. Unfavorable outcomes occurred in 12 patients (5.5%); these outcomes included treatment failure (n = 1, 0.5%), death during treatment (n = 10, 4.5%), and relapse after initial treatment completion (n = 1, 0.5%). The median duration of treatment was 188.0 days (IQR, 181.0 to 269.0). There were no significant differences between the two groups in the median duration of treatment (188.0 days [IQR, 181.0 to 271.0] vs. 186.0 days [IQR, 181.0 to 267.5], p = 0.893). Eighty-one (36.8%) patients experienced adverse events associated with anti-TB drugs, of whom 17 (7.7%) changed medication and 38 (17.3%) discontinued and restarted medication owing to the adverse events. There were no statistically significant differences in treatment outcomes between the two groups.
Clinical treatment outcomes
Box-and-whisker plots showing the date of initiation of anti-tuberculosis (TB) treatment and positive results of mycobacterial culture. IQR, interquartile range.
Factors associated with a delayed diagnosis of TB
Table 4 shows the results of univariate and multivariate logistic regression analyses that estimated the ORs of missed TB. On univariate analysis, six variables were associated with missed TB diagnosis, namely, old age, high BMI, immunocompromised status, absence of a cavitating lesion, absence of sputum production, and negative PCR results or no PCR testing. The following variables remained significant in the final multivariate analysis: older age (OR, 1.030; 95% CI, 1.012 to 1.048; p = 0.001), high BMI (OR, 1.114; 95% CI, 1.004 to 1.237; p = 0.042), and negative PCR results (OR, 9.551; 95% CI, 4.925 to 18.521; p < 0.001).
Univariate and multivariate logistic regression analysis of variables that may have contributed to a missed TB diagnosis
DISCUSSION
In this study, we found that the diagnosis of more than half of all patients with smear-negative pulmonary TB (53.2%) was delayed until the confirmation of positive culture results. Such a delay could contribute to disease transmission within the hospital [10] and community. Patients with a delayed diagnosis of TB were older, had higher BMIs, and were more likely to have negative PCR results. Thus, these were factors that could potentially delay diagnosis and treatment of smear-negative pulmonary TB.
Older age was an important factor associated with missed TB diagnosis, a finding consistent with the results of previous studies [11-13]. In elderly people, clinical symptoms and radiographic findings of TB are known to be less typical and less specific [12,14], making it easier for TB to be confused with other diseases [13]. Atypical clinical manifestations of TB in elderly patients may lead to delayed diagnosis and treatment, which may be associated with poor treatment outcomes. Furthermore, because adverse reactions are more common in elderly patients undergoing anti-TB treatment [15,16], clinicians are more likely to hesitate to initiate anti-TB treatment, which can cause a delay in the diagnosis and treatment of such patients with smear-negative pulmonary TB. Previous studies have shown that the mortality rate of TB increases with older age [17]. The higher mortality rate associated with TB in elderly patients was because of underlying comorbidities, deterioration of the immune system, and delays in initiating anti-TB treatment [18]. Therefore, efforts to improve early detection and treatment in the elderly population are needed. TB is often difficult to diagnose; thus, even if typical respiratory symptoms of TB are not present, clinicians should consider the possibility of TB in elderly patients living in areas with a considerable TB burden.
In our study, BMI was significantly higher in the missed TB group than in the control group. We, therefore, assumed that clinicians may be less likely to suspect TB in patients with higher BMI, although there is limited in-depth evidence to support this assumption. Although there were significant differences in BMI in the two groups, the mean BMIs in both groups were within the normal weight range according to the WHO guidelines.
According to the Korean TB guidelines [8], broad-spectrum antibiotics—except fluoroquinolones—could be used to rule out pulmonary TB in clinical settings. However, in our study, only 38% of patients who had a possible diagnosis of pulmonary TB were treated with broad-spectrum antibiotics before their diagnosis. This might be explained by the high performance rate of chest CT (98% in our study) and easy accessibility of bronchoscopy at our institution. At our facility, when a clinician suspects pulmonary TB through chest radiographs, they tend to perform chest CT and bronchoscopic examinations to achieve an accurate diagnosis, rather than initiate a trial of broad-spectrum antibiotics in our situation.
Rapid molecular diagnostic tools have improved the diagnostic yield of TB. Our analysis revealed that positive PCR results were associated with a faster diagnosis. However, we also found that the sensitivity of PCR testing was only 47.8%. This was probably related to the properties of smear-negative TB, i.e., paucibacillary TB with low bacillary load or enzymes in the sputum, which inhibits the amplification reaction. Previous studies reported that Xpert MTB/RIF results had a sensitivity ranging from 47% to 87% [19] in the setting of smear-negative pulmonary TB. However, in real-world practice, the sensitivity of Xpert for the detection of TB is inadequate when few bacilli are present in the clinical specimen. Therefore, various attempts have been made to increase the sensitivity of the diagnosis. Although a recent report showed that the sensitivity of the Xpert MTB/RIF Ultra assay (63%) was superior to that of the Xpert MTB RIF assay (46%), neither test’s sensitivity was sufficiently high in the setting of smear-negative pulmonary TB [20]. Thus, the development of further rapid and sensitive diagnostic tools for paucibacillary TB is warranted to prevent the delayed diagnosis of possibly infectious cases of pulmonary TB.
This study had some limitations. First, our study was a single-center trial, and the results may not be applicable to other settings. Second, the retrospective design of this study was limited to the review of medical records and our data may, therefore, not be as accurate as data collected within the context of a prospective study. Thus, further prospective studies are required to confirm our results.
In conclusion, we identified clinical characteristics and risk factors associated with missed TB diagnosis in patients who initiated anti-TB treatment after receiving confirmed positive culture results. These factors could provide clues and explain why the diagnosis of TB was delayed in the missed TB group. Carefully considering the possibility of TB in an elderly population, even when symptoms are atypical, and performing diagnostic tests—including radiological imaging and molecular assays—can help clinicians with the early detection of TB.
KEY MESSAGE
1. Patients with a delayed diagnosis of tuberculosis (TB) were older, had a higher body mass index, and were more likely to have negative polymerase chain reaction results than those in whom empirical treatment was initiated before positive cultures.
2. The development of further rapid and sensitive diagnostic tools for paucibacillary TB is necessary to prevent the delayed diagnosis of pulmonary TB.
Notes
No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.