Prevalence of thyroid nodules and their associated clinical parameters: a large-scale, multicenter-based health checkup study
Article information
Abstract
Background/Aims
We evaluated the prevalence and characteristics of thyroid nodules detected by thyroid ultrasound (US) at health checkups and the associated clinical parameters.
Methods
A total of 72,319 subjects who underwent thyroid US at three health checkup centers in Korea from January 2004 to December 2010 were included in this study. The correlations between the presence of thyroid nodules and other clinical parameters were analyzed.
Results
The prevalence of thyroid nodules and cysts was 34.2% (n = 24,757). Thyroid nodules were more prevalent in women and older age groups. Among the subjects with thyroid nodules with size information (n = 24,686), 18,833 (76.3%) had nodules measuring ≤ 1.0 cm. Women and older age groups showed higher proportion of larger nodules. Percentage of women, age, body mass index (BMI), waist circumference, body fat composition, blood pressure, and the level of fasting glucose, total cholesterol, and low density lipoprotein cholesterol were higher in the subjects with thyroid nodules compared to those without nodules. The prevalence of metabolic syndrome and overt/subclinical thyrotoxic state was higher in the subjects with thyroid nodules. In the multivariable logistic regression analysis, women, age, BMI, metabolic syndrome, and thyrotoxicosis were independently associated with the presence of thyroid nodules.
Conclusions
The high prevalence of thyroid nodules in people who underwent thyroid US at a health checkup suggests that increased detection of thyroid nodules resulted in an increased prevalence in the general population. However, metabolic disturbances may also have contributed to the increase in thyroid nodule prevalence in Korea.
INTRODUCTION
Thyroid nodules are diagnosed increasingly in clinical practice. The increasing detection rate of small and non-symptomatic thyroid nodules by various imaging methods has resulted in a high prevalence of thyroid nodules among the general population [1,2]. A previous study reported that higher levels of health-care access are associated with a higher incidence of thyroid nodules and cancers [3]. In Korea, the level of health-care access is very high; for example, > 60% of the population has undergone a health checkup in the preceding 2 years [4]. The prevalence of thyroid nodules has increased rapidly in Korea. Previous single-center studies in the mid-2000 reported a prevalence rates of 28.3% to 42.4% and 14.1% to 29.1% in asymptomatic women and men, respectively [5-8]. Despite the high probability that this is a health checkup-driven increase in the detection of thyroid pathology, large-scale and multicenter-based studies of the prevalence and characteristics of thyroid nodules detected by thyroid sonography at health checkups are lacking in Korea.
The contribution of the increasing detection rate is a widely accepted explanation for the increasing prevalence of thyroid nodules. It is well established that thyroid nodule prevalence depends on factors such as the detection method, sex, age, iodine intake, and radiation exposure [9]. Other risk factors including metabolic parameters have received attention recently. Previous studies have shown that insulin resistance was associated with increased thyroid nodule prevalence in iodine-deficient and -sufficient areas [10,11]. A recent study in China also reported that hypertension, prediabetes, and diabetes were independent risk factors for thyroid nodules [12]. In Korea, body size including height, weight, and body mass index (BMI) were reported to be associated with the presence of thyroid nodules in women [13].
In this study, we conducted a large-scale, multicenter-based study of 72,319 subjects who underwent thyroid ultrasound (US) at health checkups to investigate the prevalence and characteristics of thyroid nodules and their associated clinical parameters in the healthy Korean population.
METHODS
Subjects
Data were collected from three health checkup centers; Seoul National University Hospital Healthcare System Gangnam Center (SNUH-HSGC, Seoul, Korea), Seoul National University Bundang Hospital Health Promotion Center (SNUBH-HPC, Seongnam, Korea), and Seoul Metropolitan Government Seoul National University Boramae Medical Center Health Promotion Center (SNUBMC-HPC, Seoul, Korea). A total of 254,222 health checkups were performed from January 2004 to December 2010. Among these cases, thyroid US was performed in 100,971 cases. After excluding checkups of the 495 subjects who had undergone thyroid surgery and detecting repeated checkups, a total of 72,319 subjects were included in this study. In case of repeated checkups, data of the first checkup were used in the analyses. We did not exclude the subjects with other medical history, including diabetes, hypertension, dyslipidemia, and thyroid dysfunction as well as the subjects using any kind of medication, including thyroid hormone or antithyroid drugs. Informed consent was obtained. This study was approved by the Institutional Review Boards of the SNUH (H-1106-113-367), SNUBH (B-1303/194-109), and SNUBMC (26-2013-15/042).
Anthropometric parameters
We measured the height and weight of subjects in light clothing and without shoes to the nearest 0.1 cm and 0.1 kg, respectively. BMI was calculated as the ratio between weight and the square of height, and was expressed in kg/m2. Waist circumference was measured at the mid-point between the lateral iliac crest and the lowest rib. Total body fat percentage was determined using bioelectrical impedance analysis (Inbody 720, Biospace, Seoul, Korea). A standard mercury sphygmomanometer was used to measure systolic blood pressure (SBP) and diastolic blood pressure.
Biochemical and hormonal parameters
Plasma glucose concentration was measured in the 12-hour-fasted state using the glucose oxidase method (Hitachi 747 chemistry analyzer, Hitachi, Tokyo, Japan). Glycosylated hemoglobin (HbA1c) level was measured using a Bio-Rad Variant II Turbo HPLC analyzer (Bio-Rad, Hercules, CA, USA). The serum concentrations of aspartate aminotransferase (AST), alanine aminotransferase (ALT), γ-glutamyl transpeptidase (GGT), blood urea nitrogen (BUN), creatinine, uric acid, total cholesterol, triglycerides, low density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C), and high density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C) were measured with a Hitachi 747 chemistry analyzer. The concentrations of serum free thyroxine (T4) and thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) were measured using immunoradiometric assays (free T4, DiaSorin S.p.A., Saluggia, Italy; TSH, CIS bio international, Gif-sur-Yvette, France). The reference ranges were 0.7 to 1.8 ng/dL and 0.4 to 4.1 mIU/L for free T4 and TSH, respectively.
Classification of thyroid function status
The subjects were divided in five categories based on their thyroid function status: (1) overt hypothyroid state was defined as a TSH level > 4.10 mIU/L with a free T4 level < 0.7 ng/dL; (2) subclinical hypothyroid state was defined as a TSH level > 4.10 mIU/L with a normal free T4 level (0.7 to 1.8 ng/dL); (3) euthyroid state was defined as a normal TSH level (0.40 to 4.10 mIU/L); (4) subclinical thyrotoxic state was defined as a TSH level < 0.40 mIU/L with a normal free T4 level; and (5) overt thyrotoxic state was defined as a TSH level < 0.40 mIU/L with a free T4 level > 1.8 ng/dL. We did not consider the use of thyroid hormone and antithyroid drugs in defining thyroid function status.
Diagnosis of metabolic syndrome
According to guidelines from the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute and the American Heart Association [14], metabolic syndrome (MetS) is diagnosed when a patient has at least three of the following five conditions: (1) fasting glucose ≥ 100 mg/dL or receiving drug therapy for hyperglycemia; (2) blood pressure ≥ 130/85 mmHg or receiving drug therapy for hypertension; (3) triglycerides ≥ 150 mg/dL or receiving drug therapy for hypertriglyceridemia; (4) HDL-C < 40 mg/dL in men or < 50 mg/dL in women or receiving drug therapy for reduced HDL-C; and (5) waist circumference ≥ 90 cm in men or ≥ 80 cm in women.
Thyroid ultrasound and the classification of thyroid nodules
All ultrasonographic examinations on the thyroid were performed in each health checkup center by several radiologists using high-resolution US equipped with 7.5 to 12 or 8 to 15 MHz linear transducers. Thyroid nodules were defined as one or more discrete lesions that were within the thyroid gland but were radiologically distinct from the surrounding thyroid parenchyma. The length, width, and depth of each nodule were measured at their longest aspect on the US images, which were saved as Digital Imaging and Communications in Medicine images. All US reports were also saved as digital text. We extracted data of the presence and size of nodules from the free text of the thyroid US reports using a computerized keyword extraction method (Java Development Kit version 1.7, Oracle Corp., Redwood Shores, CA, USA). All extracted data from 72,319 cases of thyroid US report were reviewed by a medical record administrator and he fixed typo errors and corrected the data according to the standardized input format. These preliminarily reviewed data were re-reviewed by two physicians (H.Y.A. and K.W.K.). These physicians reevaluated the digital images of 10,594 cases (H.Y.A., 5,231 cases; K.W.K., 5,363 cases) harboring the keyword “cyst” or “colloid” without “nodule” and assigned them to one of two categories. According to the lesion’s content, a lesion in which the cystic portion comprised ≥ 95% of the volume was defined as a pure cyst, and a lesion in which the solid portion comprised 6% to 100% of the volume was defined as a nodule. If the extracted data harbored keywords “cyst” and “nodule” in one subject, this was classified as a nodule. Seventy-one subjects whose extracted data harboring “nodule” without size information were excluded in the analyses including size information. In the subjects with multiple nodules, the size of the largest thyroid nodule was used in the analyses.
Statistical analyses
Values with normal distribution were expressed as mean ± SD, and values with nonnormal distribution were expressed as median (interquartile range). The anthropometric and metabolic parameters were compared between the subjects with and without thyroid nodules using Student t test, chi-square test, or a linear-by-linear association test. Multivariable logistic regression analysis was used to estimate multiple correlations between the presence of thyroid nodules and other factors. All statistical analyses were performed using SAS statistical software version 9.4 (SAS Institute, Cary, NC, USA) and Stata/MP version 14 (StataCorp LP, College Station, Texas, USA). Data with a p < 0.05 were considered significant.
RESULTS
Prevalence of thyroid nodules and pure cysts in subjects who underwent thyroid ultrasound at health checkups A total of 72,319 subjects (men:women, 36,710:35,609) who underwent thyroid US in their health checkups were included in this study. Mean age of included subjects was 49.5 ± 10.3 years and mean BMI was 23.5 ± 3.0 kg/m2. Thyroid nodules were found in 24,757 subjects (34.2%) and 9,060 subjects (12.5%) had only pure cysts. Among the 36,710 men, 9,919 subjects (27.0%) and 4,169 (11.4%) were diagnosed with thyroid nodules and pure cysts, respectively. Among the 35,609 women, 14,838 subjects (41.7%) and 4,891 (13.7%) were diagnosed with nodules and pure cysts, respectively. The thyroid nodule prevalence increased with age in both men and women (Table 1) but the prevalence of pure cysts did not differ according to age (data not shown). In all subjects and in each age group, thyroid nodule prevalence was higher in women than in men (Table 1). The thyroid nodule prevalence per year in those who underwent thyroid US did not change from 2004 (32.9%) to 2010 (36.1%).
The prevalence of thyroid nodules according to age and sex
Size distribution of thyroid nodules
Among the 24,686 subjects diagnosed as thyroid nodules with specific size information, 18,833 (76.3%) had nodules measuring ≤ 1.0 cm (Table 2). Women and older age groups showed a higher proportion of nodules measuring > 1.0 cm (Table 2).
Size-distribution of thyroid nodules with the longest diameter
Comparison of anthropometric and metabolic parameters according to the presence of thyroid nodules
After excluding 9,060 subjects who had only pure cysts, we divided the remaining 63,188 subjects into two groups: those without thyroid nodule (non-nodular group) and those with thyroid nodules (nodular group). Between these two groups, subjects with thyroid nodules were older and showed higher percentage of women than those without thyroid nodule (Table 3). BMI, waist circumference, body fat composition, blood pressure, and the level of fasting glucose, HbA1c, BUN, total cholesterol, HDL-C, and LDL-C were higher in the nodular group in compared with the non-nodular group (Table 3). The concentrations of AST, ALT, GGT, creatinine, uric acid, triglycerides, and TSH were lower in the nodular groups in compared with non-nodular group (Table 3). The prevalence of MetS was higher in the nodular group and the subjects in the nodular group had higher number of components satisfying MetS criteria (Table 3). The nodular group showed a higher frequency of overt/subclinical thyrotoxic state and a lower frequency of overt/subclinical hypothyroid state (Table 3).
Comparison of anthropometric and metabolic parameters according to the presence and size of thyroid nodules
Clinical parameters associated with the presence of thyroid nodules
In the comparison of anthropometric and metabolic parameters according to the presence and size of thyroid nodules, clinical parameters included in the components of MetS showed differences according to the presence of thyroid nodule. Therefore, we performed the logistic regression analyses to identify independent associations between the presence of thyroid nodules and other clinical parameters including the components of MetS. Being female, older age, higher level of BMI, waist circumference, and SBP, lower HDL-C, and overt/subclinical thyrotoxic state were independently associated with the presence of thyroid nodules (Table 4, model 1). In the analysis including the presence of MetS as an independent variable showed female, older age, higher BMI, MetS, and overt/subclinical thyrotoxic state were independently associated with the presence of thyroid nodules (Table 4, model 2). The number of components satisfying MetS criteria was also independently associated with the presence of thyroid nodules (Table 4, model 3)
Clinical factors associating the presence of thyroid nodules
DISCUSSION
This study is the first multicenter-based health check-up study investigating the prevalence of thyroid nodules and their associating clinical parameters in Korea. In this study, the prevalence of thyroid nodules at health checkups was 34.0% (27.0% in men, 41.7% in women), and various clinical factors, including sex, age, BMI, MetS, and thyroid function, were independently associated with the presence of thyroid nodules. We distinguished thyroid pure cysts from thyroid nodules and excluded pure cysts in the nodular group because thyroid pure cysts have very low risk of malignancy and their clinical importance is different from thyroid solid nodules [15,16]. Our results showing similar prevalence of thyroid pure cysts in each group of age also suggest different pathophysiology between thyroid pure cysts and solid nodules. We also excluded pure cysts in the non-nodular group because we intended to compare the subjects without any focal lesion and those with thyroid nodules. Previous single-center studies in Korea have shown a wide range of thyroid nodule prevalence of 14.1% to 40.9% because of the inclusion of different study populations with varying sex and age compositions [5-8]. Studies performed in the United States, Europe, and China have also reported the prevalence ranged 19.0% to 46.6% for thyroid incidentalomas in screening with thyroid US [12,17-19]. A previous study of 8,307 subjects who underwent health checkups in a single health checkup center in Korea from January 2002 to December 2003 reported a prevalence of 41.0% for thyroid nodules and a higher prevalence in women (29.0% in men, 42.2% in women) and in older age groups [6]. We found a similar prevalence of thyroid nodules as that reported by previous studies, but we found a more consistent results showing women’s higher prevalence of thyroid nodules in every age group. We also demonstrated a higher proportion of larger nodules in women and a continuing increase of the prevalence and size of thyroid nodules according to age. To our knowledge, this study includes the largest population (72,319 subjects) and is the first multicenter study to investigate the prevalence of thyroid nodules detected at health check-ups in Korea. Therefore, our study demonstrates stronger sex and age differences in the prevalence and size of thyroid nodules than do previous studies. The thyroid nodules detected in asymptomatic healthy subjects are generally small and, as expected, we found that 76.1% of nodules measured ≤ 1.0 cm in maximal diameter. This size distribution is also consistent with that reported in previous studies [6,20].
Some studies reported that the presence of thyroid nodules was associated with metabolic disturbances [11-13,21,22]. In earlier studies, the prevalence of thyroid nodules was higher in subjects with the MetS and impaired glucose metabolism [11,21], and those with thyroid nodules had a higher prevalence of obesity, the metabolic syndrome, prediabetes, and diabetes [12,13,22]. We also observed an independent association between the presence of thyroid nodules and a higher BMI and MetS. Interestingly, the number of components satisfying MetS criteria was associated with the presence of thyroid nodules. One possible mechanism to explain the association between thyroid nodules and metabolic disturbances is a TSH-dependent mechanism including leptin signaling. Leptin directly and indirectly increases the secretion of thyrotropin-releasing hormone, which results in an increase of TSH secretion [23]. Serum leptin concentration increases in proportion to increasing fat mass, and insulin administration increases serum leptin levels [24,25]. Thus, it has been postulated that obesity and insulin resistance increase TSH secretion via leptin signaling, which results in thyroid volume expansion and nodule formation. However, in our data, TSH level was lower in the subjects with thyroid nodules compared with those without nodules, and the nodular group had a higher frequency of overt/subclinical thyrotoxic state and lower frequency of overt/subclinical hypothyroid state. One previous study found no association between the TSH level and thyroid nodule presence despite finding an association between TSH level and thyroid volume [11]. Thus, TSH-independent mechanisms might be involved in the association between thyroid nodule formation and metabolic disturbances.
Insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1) promotes the progression of mitosis in many types of cells and results in cell proliferation, differentiation, and apoptosis [26]. This potent mitogen functions through its binding to the IGF-1 receptor (IGF-1R), and the signal transduction through IGF-1R leads to abnormal hyperplasia, differentiation, and apoptosis of thyrocytes [27-29]. A recent study reported that the expression of IGF-1 and IGF-1R was significantly higher in the tissues of follicular adenomas and nodular goiters compared with normal thyroid tissues [29]. It is well-known, meanwhile, that IGF-1 and IGF-1R share structural homology with insulin and the insulin receptor, respectively [30]. Taken together, hyperinsulinemia in obesity and the insulin-resistant status might induce thyroid nodule formation through the insulin IGF-1-signaling pathway. This insulin/IGF-1 pathway could be a TSH-independent mechanism that might explain the association between thyroid nodule formation and metabolic disturbances.
As mentioned above, overt/subclinical thyrotoxic state (lower TSH level) was associated with an increased chance of having thyroid nodules, and overt/subclinical hypothyroid state (higher TSH level) was associated with a decreased chance in the present study. Because TSH is a major regulator of the growth and differentiation of thyrocytes, the TSH level had been expected to be higher in subjects with thyroid nodules than in those without nodules. Although we cannot clearly explain our results contrary to expectations, there is a possibility that our data may include subjects who had already been diagnosed of thyroid nodule and maintained levothyroxine for TSH suppression at the time of health checkup because we did not exclude the subjects using any kind of medication, including thyroid hormone or antithyroid drugs. In addition, extremely high prevalence of “hot nodule” could result in this association. However, our data from over 72,000 cases consistently demonstrated the association between the higher prevalence of thyroid nodule and the lower TSH level after adjusting other clinical factors. Further studies to investigate the underlying mechanisms of this association are required.
This study highlights some important clinical implications. Our data showing a high prevalence of thyroid nodules in the subjects who underwent thyroid US at health checkups and increasing prevalence in older age groups indicate that the popularity of thyroid US has contributed to the increase in detection of thyroid nodules and cancer in the general population. This contribution of thyroid US is also supported by the observations that the nodule prevalence did not change with time in the subjects who underwent thyroid US and that the absolute number of people receiving thyroid US has increased every year from 4,804 cases in 2004 to 19,939 cases in 2010. The result showing that most of the thyroid nodules detected at health checkups measured ≤ 1.0 cm is also consistent with the contribution of thyroid US to the high prevalence of thyroid nodules. Nevertheless, our data confirm an association between thyroid nodule presence and metabolic disturbance, including obesity and MetS. Considering the increases in the prevalence of obesity, MetS, and diabetes in Korea, our data suggest that metabolic disturbances may play a role in the recent increase in the prevalence of thyroid nodules.
The limitations of this study include the cross-sectional study design. Although we adjusted for possible covariates, we could not confirm a causal link between the clinical parameters and thyroid nodule presence in this study. Investigating the risk factors for newly developed thyroid nodules in a prospective or retrospective cohort study may improve the strength of future studies. Another limitation is the lack of morphological analysis and further information about the thyroid nodules. We could not include the data of multiplicity, echogenicity, border irregularity, microcalcification, or spongi-form morphology of thyroid nodules because we extracted the data from free text of US reports using a computerized keyword extraction method. Investigation of the clinical parameters associated with thyroid nodules, such as suspicious morphology or cytologic findings, may have strong clinical impact. We found differences in several parameters, including the concentrations of AST, ALT, GGT, BUN, creatinine, and uric acid, between the nodular and non-nodular groups. However, the differences were not clinically significant, and we included some clinically applicable parameters in multivariable analyses.
In conclusion, we conducted a multicenter study to investigate the prevalence of thyroid nodules detected at health checkups and their associated clinical parameters. The high prevalence of thyroid nodules detected by thyroid US at health checkups suggests that increased detection of thyroid nodules has resulted in an increasing prevalence in the general population. However, the association between thyroid nodule presence and metabolic disturbances, including obesity and MetS, suggests that these metabolic disturbances may have also contributed to the increase in the prevalence of thyroid nodules in Korea.
KEY MESSAGE
1. The prevalence of thyroid nodules detected by thyroid ultrasound at health checkups was 34.2%.
2. Thyroid nodules were more prevalent in women and older age groups.
3. Thyroid nodule presence was associated with sex, age, body mass index, and metabolic syndrome.
4. The association between thyroid nodule presence and metabolic disturbances suggests that metabolic disturbances may have also contributed to the increase in the prevalence of thyroid nodules in Korea.
Notes
No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.
Acknowledgements
This study was supported by National Evidence-based Healthcare Collaborating Agency, NECA (NA13-003) and by the Research Grant Number CB 2011-03-01 of Korean Foundation for Cancer Research.