METHODS
This study was carried out at emergency services of Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh, a tertiary care referral hospital in Northern India. More than 75,000 patients visit emergency of this institute annually. We reviewed clinical records of all patients of primary pyomyositis presenting in emergency services from July 2007 onwards, and relevant clinical details were recorded in a predesigned instrument. From July 2007 to December 2012, records of patients were obtained from medical record library, whereas patients were recruited prospectively from January 2013 till December 2013. The medical record library uses the ICD-10 (International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems 10) system for classification of diseases. Each disease condition is assigned a unique code number. We retrieved medical records of primary pyomyositis patients using the specific code number assigned to this disease entity and recorded data of those patients of primary pyomyositis presenting in emergency services. Primary pyomyositis was defined as an intramuscular infection involving one or more of the skeletal muscle groups in the absence of adjacent skin, soft tissue, or bone infection [
1-
3]. Age, sex, history of muscle trauma, duration of illness, presenting manifestations, comorbid conditions, hospital course, treatment instituted, complications encountered, and hospital outcome of these patients were recorded as well. Investigations including complete blood count, differential blood count, erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR), liver and renal function tests, gram stain and culture of the pus from muscles, acid-fast bacilli (AFB) stain/culture and blood culture reports were also recorded. Radiological investigations including chest X-ray, X-ray dorsolumbar spine, 2D Echo, ultrasonography, computed tomography (CT), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) reports wherever available/done were recorded in a predesigned instrument. The Institution Ethics Committee approved the study. Informed consent was obtained from patients who were recruited prospectively from January 2013 till December 2013.
Sepsis was defined as the presence of a clinically identified site of infection and two or more of the following: temperature > 38℃ or < 36℃; heart rate > 90 beats per minute; respiratory rate > 20 breaths per minute or PaCO2 < 32 mmHg; and white blood cell count > 12,000/μL, < 4,000/μL, or > 10% immature forms (i.e., bands), altered mental status (Glasgow coma scale [GCS] < 9), significant edema or positive fluid balance (> 20 mL/kg over 24 hours), hyperglycemia (glucose > 120 mg/dL) in the absence of diabetes [
14]. Various laboratory abnormalities were defined using cut-off values as follows: anemia (hemoglobin < 13 g/dL for male, < 12 g/dL for female, non-pregnant); leukocytosis (total leukocyte count [TLC] > 12,000/μL), leucopenia (TLC < 4,000/μL); elevated ESR (> 20 in the first hour); hypoalbuminemia (albumin < 3.5 g/dL); and impaired renal function (blood urea nitrogen > 50 mg/dL and/or serum creatinine > 1.20 mg/dL).
Statistical analysis was done using the statistical software SPSS version 20.0 (IBM Co., Armonk, NY, USA). Data was presented as mean ± standard deviation (SD) when distributed normally and as median with interquartile range (IQR), if the distribution was skewed. We divided study group into two subgroups of survivors and non-survivors and various parameters between these two subgroups were compared to identify the parameters associated with in-hospital mortality. We also compared variables among subgroups of patients with positive and negative pus culture report; patients with gram-negative and positive bacterial growth in pus; patients with methicillin-sensitive Staphylococcus aureus (MSSA) and methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) infection; and patients with or without underlying medical illness. Continuous, normally distributed variables were compared with Student t test, and for non-normally distributed continuous variables, non-parametric test like, Mann-Whitney U test was used. Categorical variables were compared by Fisher exact test. We also compared various variables among patients with different stages of illness at presentation. For normally distributed variables between three groups, analysis of variance test was used. For non-normally distributed variables, Kruskal-Wallis test was used. p < 0.05 were considered significant. All statistical tests performed were 2-tailed.
DISCUSSION
This observational cohort study re-emphasizes the fact that primary pyomyositis is not an uncommon disease condition. Myalgia, fever, anemia, leukocytosis, raised ESR, and hypoalbuminemia were found in a large number of patients. Patients with underlying medical diseases were older, had a higher rate of gram-negative bacterial infections and were more likely to receive initial inappropriate antibiotic therapy. Patients with positive pus culture report had longer hospital stay and the higher rate of complications as compared to patients with negative pus culture report. Lower first-day serum albumin, initial inappropriate antibiotic therapy and advanced form of the disease at presentation were associated with increased in-hospital mortality.
Pyomyositis is primary infection of striated muscles, usually presenting as an intramuscular abscess. Sometimes it may present as a diffuse inflammatory process without abscess formation. This infective condition is seen in all age groups, but maximum number of patients are reported in age group 10 to 40 years [
1-
3]. The mean age of our study cohort was 29.9 years. In a descriptive review, patients from temperate regions were older (mean age, 34 years) as compared to cases reported from tropical countries (mean age, 28 years) [
10]. This observation to some extent could be due to the higher number of patients with underlying predisposing conditions developing this infective disease in temperate areas. Studies reported both from tropical and temperate countries found patients with underlying medical disease conditions were older as was the case in index study as well [
5,
10,
15]. Male preponderance noted in this study is reported previously in various studies as well [
1-
3].
The pathogenesis of this infective disease process is not precisely known till date. Healthy striated muscle is considered intrinsically resistant to bacterial infections as iron required for bacterial proliferation is sequestered by myoglobin. Local muscle tissue structure is altered by trauma, obvious or many times unrecognized, releasing sequestered iron from myoglobin. Abundant iron available after injury provides a suitable milieu resulting in rapid growth and proliferation of organisms implanted in damaged muscles from a bacteremic episode [
1-
3,
6]. Various studies have documented history of trauma to the affected muscles in 5% to 50% of patients [
1-
13]. In our study as well only 16 patients (25.8%) gave the history of trauma to affected muscles, so other unknown factors or occult muscle injury/damage must also exist. Several other mechanisms postulated in the pathogenesis of pyomyositis include nutritional deficiencies, viral and parasitic infections, lack of immunity against
Staphylococcus, although many of these are not fully substantiated [
1-
3,
6]. Pyomyositis was initially thought to be confined to tropical areas predominantly affecting young and healthy populations with no underlying medical comorbidities. In one of the largest series of 205 cases of 112 patients reported from Nigeria, none of the patients had underlying medical illness [
6]. On the other hand, a descriptive review of patients over two decades from USA showed 119 patients (48%) with underlying medical conditions, including diabetes, malignancy, chronic liver disease, and hematologic and rheumatologic conditions [
10]. Twelve patients (19.35%) had underlying medical diseases in our index study. Out of 155 patients diagnosed with pyomyositis over two decades in our institution including present study, 55 (35.48%) had underlying medical disorders [
3,
4]. Differences in clinicoepidemiologic profile seen previously in patients of pyomyositis from temperate and tropical regions is thus getting blurred, which is getting reflected even in disease nomenclature with suggestions being made to rename this entity more appropriately as primary pyomyositis instead of tropical or temperate pyomyositis.
Early diagnosis of pyomyositis becomes difficult due to its relative unfamiliarity among physicians, non-specific early clinical symptoms and signs; and often lead to misdiagnosis. There are three discrete stages in the natural history of primary pyomyositis. This disease progresses from initial diffuse inflammation or invasive stage to focal abscess formation (suppurative stage) to late stage of dissemination and organ dysfunction [
1-
3,
6]. The majority of patients in index study presented in the suppurative stage similar to previous studies [
1-
10]. Muscle pain was seen universally in all patients, but importantly fever was noted in 48 patients (77.4%), similar to two studies reported from the same institution [
4,
5]. Leucocytosis with the shift to left and raised ESR was observed in the majority of our patients, as reported in previous studies [
1-
13]. These laboratory parameters with only muscle pain must prompt the clinician to keep pyomyositis as one of diagnostic possibility. We noticed higher level of mean ESR and TLC across three stages of illness at presentation, highest documented in the disseminated stage of infection. Mean serum protein and albumin at admission also showed graded relationship being lowest in the disseminated stage. ESR and TLC are the non-specific markers of acute inflammation while serum albumin is negative acute phase reactant [
16]. Patients with infection/inflammation can have low serum albumin level. Various pathogenetic pathways include the decrease in albumin production, accelerated catabolism and increased permeability of the microvasculature leading to the excessive transcapillary passage of albumin to interstitial space. There is also diversion of synthetic pathway to other proteins of acute phase response [
17-
19]. These infection/inflammation induced mechanisms probably led to hypoalbuminemia in index study as well.
Most cases of primary pyomyositis are due to
S. aureus. It is the causative agent in the majority of cases, accounting for up to 90% of infections reported from the tropics and up to 60% to 70% of cases reported from temperate areas [
1-
3]. Our study also showed the predominance of
S. aureus as the causative agent. Out of 27 patients with growth of gram-positive organisms in drained pus, MSSA was isolated in 18 and MRSA in eight patients. Resistance to methicillin, a penicillinase-stable β-lactam was first noticed among
S. aureus in the United Kingdom in 1961 [
20]. These strains are multidrug resistant. Cases of infections caused by a different MRSA strains, CA-MRSA, infecting apparently healthy individuals without any healthcare contact, harbouring smaller and more mobile staphylococcal cassette-chromosome types (IV and V) and susceptible to many non-β-lactam antimicrobial drugs were reported from USA in 1990s initially [
21,
22]. These MRSA strains since then have spread throughout world causing variety of infections. There are case reports and series reporting pyomyositis caused by both of these strains in medical literature. But differentiation between healthcare-associated MRSA (HA-MRSA) and CA-MRSA strains based on genetic markers and virulence factors is getting blurred lately with increasing number of isolates showing characteristics of both HA-MRSA and CA-MRSA pathogens [
23-
25]. This could possibly be due to exchange of genetic materials between these strains. We also documented eight cases of pyomyositis caused by MRSA strain. Significantly higher number of MRSA related pyomyositis patients received in-appropriate antibiotic therapy initially. There was no difference in hospital mortality. There was although trend towards longer hospital stay in patients with MRSA pyomyositis. In a retrospective case series of 39 adult patients with pyomyositis, oxacillin-resistant
S. aureus comprised 25% (8/32) of infections due to
S. aureus. They found increasing number of cases of oxacillin-resistance during study from one of 18
S. aureus isolates from 1994 to 2004 to seven of 14 isolates from 2004 to 2006 [
26]. In our institute as well, studies have shown increasing number of MRSA isolates from none during 1992 to 1999 to four during study period of 7 and half years from 2000 to June 2007 from pus culture [
4,
5]. In the index study of 6 and half years duration, eight MRSA isolates were reported from drained pus. Number of studies have tried to discern impact of methicillin-resistance on hospital outcomes including mortality rates among patients infected with
S. aureus. These studies yielded variable results. A single-center prospective study by Melzer et al. [
27] showed that MRSA infection was not associated with increased mortality. Similar result was also reported in a study by Wolkewitz et al. [
28]. Number of studies on the other hand, reported hospital mortality rate significantly higher in infections caused by MRSA strain. As patients with MRSA infection are more likely than patients with MSSA infection to be older, to have more comorbid illnesses and greater severity of illness; inadequate control of these confounding factors remained a major concern. An observational study involving cohort of 500 patients with MSSA bacteraemia, 111 patients with CA-MRSA, and 133 patients with HA-MRSA bacteraemia evaluated the impact of the MRSA strain on mortality in patients with CA-MRSA or HA-MRSA bacteraemia by comparison with mortality in patients with MSSA bacteraemia. This study concluded that infection with traditional hospital strain of MRSA was associated with a significantly higher mortality rate than infection with MSSA, independent of the confounding effect from underlying disease and acute severity of bacteraemia [
29]. Cosgrove et al. [
30] examined data from 31 cohort studies including 3,963 patients (34% of whom were infected with methicillin-resistant strains) in a meta-analysis. It showed that bacteraemia due to MRSA is associated with increased mortality compared with MSSA bacteraemia. This finding remained significant after taking care of confounding variables [
30]. As stated earlier, we did not find significant difference in duration of hospital stay and hospital mortality rate among MSSA and MRSA infected patients with pyomyositis. This result could be due to the small numbers of MSSA and MRSA pyomyositis cases in present study. Pyomyositis is usually caused by gram-positive organisms but lately increasing number of cases caused be gram-negative organisms are being reported. We also encountered 14 patients with pyomyositis caused by gram-negative organisms. In a retrospective observational study by Chiu et al. [
15], 35 cases of primary pyomyositis were identified during the study period and 23 of them had underlying medical diseases. Gram-negative organisms were isolated in seven patients (30.4%) with underlying diseases. They found that patients who suffered from primary pyomyositis with underlying diseases were older, had a higher rate of gram-negative bacterial infections, bacteraemia, and hospital mortality [
15]. Similar result was reported in a study from Indian subcontinent as well [
5]. The index study also reported that patients with comorbidities were older, had higher culture positivity with gram-negative organisms. Importantly, higher number of these patients received inappropriate antibiotics initially.
E. coli was the most common pathogenic organism isolated among patients with pyomyositis caused by gram-negative organisms. There are few case reports and small case series of
E. coli pyomyositis. Vigil et al. [
31] in a retrospective observational study analysed six cases of
E. coli pyomyositis in patients with hematologic malignancy. Two (33%) died, despite receiving carbapenem therapy. All
E. coli isolates were quinolone resistant; 55% produced an ESBL [
31]. We found four
E. coli isolates to be resistant to quinolone. Two patients (33%) with E. coli pyomyositis in index study died. Zalavras et al. [
26] retrospectively reviewed records of 39 adult patients with diabetes mellitus treated for thigh pyomyositis. Their mean age was 45 years. Gram-negative organisms were cultured in 14% (6/39) of patients and three grew
E. coli [
26]. In a retrospective descriptive review of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-negative patients with underlying medical conditions and pyomyositis, 14.3% (17/119) patients had gram-negative organisms as infecting pathogen [
10]. These findings emphasize the fact that antibiotic coverage for gram-negative organisms should be empirically initiated in patients of pyomyositis with concurrent medical disorders/immunosuppressive conditions. Interestingly, we found patients with positive pus culture report had longer hospital stay and the higher rate of complications as compared to patients with negative pus culture report. A retrospective observational study of 24 children reported from Taiwan also showed similar results [
32]. The plausible explanation could be greater load of micro-organisms leading to more marked inflammatory response which was also reflected in higher mean TLC, ESR, and lower mean serum albumin in culture positive patients, resulting in higher rate of complications. Other possible explanation could be faster reduction in load of micro-organisms from pus with appropriate antibiotics in culture negative patients resulting in lesser complications, resulting understandably in the shorter hospital stay.
The most common site of involvement was thigh muscles, followed by iliopsoas. Previous studies irrespective of the region have also noted that pyomyositis usually involves the largest muscle groups located around the pelvic girdle and lower extremities [
1-
10]. These observations further strengthen the postulation that greater degree of movement in muscle groups located around the pelvic girdle and lower extremities may cause subclinical trauma to these muscles making them more susceptible to infection by bacteria from a subsequent bacteremic episode.
The stage at presentation decides treatment options for patients with pyomyositis. Oral or intravenous antibiotics alone would suffice during the early stage of the infection, the diffuse inflammatory stage. Abscess formation, however, requires antibiotic with appropriate drainage procedure. There was no difference in mortality based on methods of drainage of pus. Six patients (9.68%) had in-hospital mortality due to complications considered related to primary pyomyositis. Lower firstday serum albumin, initial inappropriate antibiotic therapy and advanced form of the disease (late stage) at presentation were associated with increased in-hospital mortality. Serum albumin plays diverse, complex, and important roles in maintaining physiologic homeostasis [
18]. Hypoalbuminemia may either directly contribute to poor outcomes, or it could merely be a marker for other “upstream” pathologic processes such as malnutrition or infection/inflammation. It appears to be a reliable prognostic indicator in various contexts [
18,
33]. It was found to be a potent, dose-dependent independent predictor of poor outcome in a meta-analysis of 90 cohort studies with 291,433 patients. The association between hypoalbuminemia and poor outcome appeared to be independent of both nutritional status and inflammation [
34]. As stated earlier, inflammation induced by infective condition predominantly contributed to hypoalbuminemic state in our study. Initial inappropriate antibiotic therapy has been documented in studies to lead to the poorer outcome. The advanced form of the disease at presentation also would understandably have the poorer prognosis. These patients also had the greater degree of inflammation leading to greater lowering of serum albumin.
In conclusion, this study reemphasizes the fact that primary pyomyositis is not an uncommon disease entity. Patients with underlying medical diseases were older, had a higher rate of gram-negative bacterial infections and were more likely to receive initial inappropriate antibiotic therapy. Patients with positive pus culture report had longer hospital stay and the higher rate of complications. Lower first-day serum albumin, initial inappropriate antibiotic therapy and advanced form of the disease at presentation were associated with increased in-hospital mortality.